Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 12/07/1998 - 19:12 Forums: LML Archive From: by way of Marvin Kaye <marvkaye [at] olsusa.com> <dechaze [at] cardell.com> Subject: Re:Main gear hydraulic Cylinder Date: Mon, 07 Dec 1998 14:12:21 -0500 To: <lancair.list [at] olsusa.com> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> << Lancair Builders' Mail List >> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Regarding Scott Krueger's note on main gear cylinder bottoming.... This is news. About 6 months ago, a Lancair tech rep was emphatic that the NOSE gear cylinder be setup as Scott describes in order to react the loads internal to the cylinder. Issue, as was discussed here, was that the nose gear tunnel could crack. When I asked about the mains, I was told this is not a problem because of the way loads are reacted at the main cylinder attach points. And in fact, the inboard supports for the main cylinders do look "beefy". The problem of a bent cylinder rod as Scott reports may or may not have anything to do with bottoming out the cylinder internally. What would bend that (very strong) rod? How would the forces be applied to accomplish this? I ask these arcane questions because I wonder if the rod impacted the inboard linkage attach - the one the manual warns us about. Or, if it's a misallignment during the stroke that was the culprit then changing the bottoming condition won't help. Obviously, first thing I will do when I get to the shop will be to re-inspect my installation. Ed de Chazal, Rochester, Michigan. Main gear hydraulic Cylinder Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 12/08/1998 - 06:27 From: Marvin Kaye <marvkaye [at] olsusa.com> Subject: Re:Main gear hydraulic Cylinder Date: Tue, 08 Dec 1998 01:27:43 -0500 To: <lancair.list [at] olsusa.com> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> << Lancair Builders' Mail List >> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Ed de Chazal wrote: >The problem of a bent cylinder rod as Scott reports may or may not have >anything >to do with bottoming out the cylinder internally. What would bend that (very >strong) rod? How would the forces be applied to accomplish this? After reading the several replies to my original question and having spent several hours a few days ago getting the main gear cylinders setup, I think I can shed a little light on the situation. If you look at how the system performs in each direction it becomes pretty obvious that if you don't allow the cylinder to bottom out on the down stroke, when the o/c links stop the gear from any additional outboard motion, something is going to have to give. I see 3 possible scenarios if there's still piston travel left when the downlocks snap into place. First possibility, nothing happens... the hydraulic pressure will just force the o/c links into a more tightly locked position and the system will become static at that point. Second possibility, the actuator attachment arms on the o/c link fail allowing the cylinder to reach the end of its travel... highly unlikely considering the geometry and materials being used, although I suppose the attachment fittings could fail over time if the bolt holes became elongated and the assembly started to move with every cycle. Third possibility, the gear locks down, the o/c links stop their motion and the actuating rod flexes to allow the piston to bottom out in the cylinder. Also highly unlikely, given the current thickness of the piston rod, but the most likely eventuality of the three. The obvious solution to precluding any of the former things from happening is to have the actuator reach the end of its travel at the same time the o/c links snap into place. I personally don't see a way to bend the piston rod in the retraction phase, as when the gear-up pressure is applied to the actuator that piston rod is in tension, and there's no force that could be applied to it by the actuator that would impose a bending moment on it anywhere through its travel. Needless to say (but I'll say it anyway) there needs to be a means to stop the inward stroke to keep the wheel from pressing itself through the upper wing skin. Naturally, if you can adjust the inboard mounting position to a location where the final location of the gear coincides with the bottoming of the piston in the cylinder you've solved the problem and everything is hunky-dorey. Prudence would recommend, however, that you provide some means for adjusting the upstroke to allow for expansion of the tire with altitude, or to be able to fine tune the upstroke should you change tires and need to make allowances for a different tire width. The stop sleeve which is supplied with the LC20 kit is the obvious answer. I will likely have to have longer sleeves fabricated as I want to be able to have stop nuts at both the rod end and behind the sleeve. Until I'm ready for final assembly, however, and I make that last adjustment of the up travel, I'll be using a pair of washers between the stop sleeve and the end of the actuator... a dab of super glue will keep them temporarily attached to the sleeve until I arrive at its final required length. My plan is to have the stop sleeve, its locknut, whatever spacer is required, the locknut against the rod end, and the rod end itself all in intimate contact so there's no possibility of anything moving after everything is adjusted. I may even just fabricate a single locknut which is the exact length required to create that solid piece between the sop sleeve and the rod end. Time will tell. Sorry for the long-winded dissertation, but I felt that additional clarification of this matter was called for. Thanks to everyone who responded to my original question, you laid out the road map to my understanding of exactly how all that hardware in the gear well relates. <Marv>
Main gear hydraulic Cylinder Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 12/08/1998 - 06:27 From: Marvin Kaye <marvkaye [at] olsusa.com> Subject: Re:Main gear hydraulic Cylinder Date: Tue, 08 Dec 1998 01:27:43 -0500 To: <lancair.list [at] olsusa.com> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> << Lancair Builders' Mail List >> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Ed de Chazal wrote: >The problem of a bent cylinder rod as Scott reports may or may not have >anything >to do with bottoming out the cylinder internally. What would bend that (very >strong) rod? How would the forces be applied to accomplish this? After reading the several replies to my original question and having spent several hours a few days ago getting the main gear cylinders setup, I think I can shed a little light on the situation. If you look at how the system performs in each direction it becomes pretty obvious that if you don't allow the cylinder to bottom out on the down stroke, when the o/c links stop the gear from any additional outboard motion, something is going to have to give. I see 3 possible scenarios if there's still piston travel left when the downlocks snap into place. First possibility, nothing happens... the hydraulic pressure will just force the o/c links into a more tightly locked position and the system will become static at that point. Second possibility, the actuator attachment arms on the o/c link fail allowing the cylinder to reach the end of its travel... highly unlikely considering the geometry and materials being used, although I suppose the attachment fittings could fail over time if the bolt holes became elongated and the assembly started to move with every cycle. Third possibility, the gear locks down, the o/c links stop their motion and the actuating rod flexes to allow the piston to bottom out in the cylinder. Also highly unlikely, given the current thickness of the piston rod, but the most likely eventuality of the three. The obvious solution to precluding any of the former things from happening is to have the actuator reach the end of its travel at the same time the o/c links snap into place. I personally don't see a way to bend the piston rod in the retraction phase, as when the gear-up pressure is applied to the actuator that piston rod is in tension, and there's no force that could be applied to it by the actuator that would impose a bending moment on it anywhere through its travel. Needless to say (but I'll say it anyway) there needs to be a means to stop the inward stroke to keep the wheel from pressing itself through the upper wing skin. Naturally, if you can adjust the inboard mounting position to a location where the final location of the gear coincides with the bottoming of the piston in the cylinder you've solved the problem and everything is hunky-dorey. Prudence would recommend, however, that you provide some means for adjusting the upstroke to allow for expansion of the tire with altitude, or to be able to fine tune the upstroke should you change tires and need to make allowances for a different tire width. The stop sleeve which is supplied with the LC20 kit is the obvious answer. I will likely have to have longer sleeves fabricated as I want to be able to have stop nuts at both the rod end and behind the sleeve. Until I'm ready for final assembly, however, and I make that last adjustment of the up travel, I'll be using a pair of washers between the stop sleeve and the end of the actuator... a dab of super glue will keep them temporarily attached to the sleeve until I arrive at its final required length. My plan is to have the stop sleeve, its locknut, whatever spacer is required, the locknut against the rod end, and the rod end itself all in intimate contact so there's no possibility of anything moving after everything is adjusted. I may even just fabricate a single locknut which is the exact length required to create that solid piece between the sop sleeve and the rod end. Time will tell. Sorry for the long-winded dissertation, but I felt that additional clarification of this matter was called for. Thanks to everyone who responded to my original question, you laid out the road map to my understanding of exactly how all that hardware in the gear well relates. <Marv>
Main gear hydraulic Cylinder
Submitted by Anonymous on